Skip to main content

Velib versus Boris Bikes

Tory Troll has posted a helpful little table first published in the Evening Standards which provides figures of comparisons between the Paris and London cycle hire schemes.

Strangely the ES manages to claim that the London scheme compares favourably with the Paris one (the biggest such scheme in the world). Judge for yourself.


































VelibLondon Cycle Hire
Number of bikes
Initially 10,648, now 20,600
6,000
Docking stations
1,451
315 (400 originally planned)
Area covered
90Km2 in 20 arrondissements
44km2
Bike weight
22.5kg
23kg
Subscribers in 1st year
198,913
As yet unknown (30,000 in 1st week)
Funding
€90m from JCDecaux (about £75m)
£140m from taxpayer + £25m from Barclays sponsorship
Annual subscription
€29 (about £21)
£45
(I have added/amended some of the info).

Still according to the ES, and because obviously too much positive bias towards Boris wouldn't be on, the "French prefer our ‘stylish and beautiful’ Boris bikes to Velib". Personally, I can see very little difference between both bikes, apart from the colour, they look pretty much the same.

And finally, there is already a conspiracy theory around the schemes.

View my growing number of posts about the scheme here.

Comments

  1. Style-wise, the Velib is much the nicer. But that shouldn't be surprising - it's French! Still, if the French can successfully run the Velib network with a 10:1 subscribers-to-bikes ration, while Boris's Bikes have a 5:1 ratio and are a nightmare, what does that say about boris's bikes?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post, I've done a comparison of my own here: http://richmondtransits.blogspot.com/2010/09/boris-bike-vs-french-velib-unfair.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. The staffing issue comes as no great surprise all JC Decaux press releases on their many schemes indicate a ratio of 1 technician to 50-60 bikes. Clear Channel who have been doing this for the longest time in Europe (since 1997) run Barcelona with a ratio of 1 to 100. The cycle trade reported that Serco had sent 4 staff for full ACT training and were internally training a further 26 staff in the months before the London scheme went live.

    The analysis commissioned for the scheme clearly stated that the tidal flows of rail and other commuters would cause problems. A balanced system requires around 50% more docking points than bikes in circulation to ensure spaces are available. A tidal flow system needs nearer to twice the provision of docking points.

    The Clear Channel systems are on their 5th or 6th generation of bikes and docking systems The Bixi system is only the second to go live - the first in Montreal was commissioned after the TfL decision was made, but the London installation required some significant changes, notably dropping the wireless palletised docking points which can be unloaded full or empty from a truck in under a minute, ready for use (in Montreal the bike and docking points come off the streets in winter when the city often gets a substantial dump of snow). London required the docking points to be fixed and hard wired, making any balancing intervention a triple handling exercise - transfer of bikes to a vehicle, transport of bike, and transfer back to a docking point.

    There is a solution, which can use the existing bikes as used by the system in Montpelier - this is to have more than one tariff, and mode of use. You have the existing 'bike sharing' tariff with the incentive to keep bikes circulating, and then you have an OV-Fiets model where a commuter hires a bike for the whole working day, parking it at work and returning it in the evening.

    OV-Fiets is a Dutch system owned and operated by the Dutch rail operator for the Dutch rail passengers, who pay an annual 'registration fee and less than £2 per day for a simple basic bike that they can collect from the station. We do actually have a UK equivalent - potentially even better - where Stagecoach hires folding bikes to season ticket holders to keep out for up to a year, bringing the bikes in only for servicing. But the practical solution is to deliver a basic bike for use between 08.00 and 18.00.

    THis can be done with minimal fuss by using palletised bikes and docking points that are stored in places like the mothballed car park under the Eurostar station at Waterloo, or the old GPO roadways at Euston, full pallets are rolled out to a collection point, replacing these as they empty. The hired bikes are parked in the massive cycle parking capacity installed in many London office buildings (Swiss REA is reported to have a 600-bike facility), and further capacity can be created using spare space in Central London Car Parks now vacated due to the C-Charge. At the end of the day bikes are returned to the pallets in the reverse of the morning process moving filled pallets to the storage pound and placing fresh empty ones to be filled as the bikes come back.

    One long established London Cycle Hire operation indicates that a long term contract hire rate of around £2 per day for a basic utility bike is viable, and selling the branding of the bikes has delivered a means to defray operating costs for Copenhagen's bike system for the past 15 years offering a variety of 'sponsors' who are now delivered by media operator J C Decaux.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Tavdy - Users per bike upper limit around 20 and 15 is healthy, More than 20 and the system starts to creak.

    Likewise hires per bike per day - once you hit 20 on a well balanced system the level of service starts to go down dramatically - although Lyon hit 25 hires/bike/day during a bus strike. Lyon has 1000 bike sponsored by HSBC - but not whole fleet.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Please leave your comment here. Note that comments are moderated and only those in French or in English will be published. Thank you for taking the time to read this blog and to leave a thought.

Popular posts from this blog

A Short History of the Elephant and Castle and Its Name

Last night I attended a lecture by local historian Stephen Humphrey who discussed the general history of the Elephant & Castle, focussing more particularly on what he called its heyday (between 1850 and 1940). This is part of a week-long art project ( The Elephant Project ) hosted in an empty unit on the first floor of the infamous shopping centre, aiming to chart some of the changes currently happening to the area. When an historian starts talking about the Elephant and Castle, there is one subject he can not possibly avoid, even if he wanted to. Indeed my unsuspecting announcement on Facebook that I was attending such talk prompted a few people to ask the dreaded question: Where does the name of the area come from, for realz? Panoramic view of the Elephant and Castle around 1960/61. Those of us less badly informed than the rest have long discarded the theory that the name comes from the linguistic deformation of "Infanta de Castille", a name which would have become at

Review: Park Avenue Cat @ Arts Theatre

As we are steadily reminded throughout the hour and half hour of Park Avenue Cat , the new play by Frank Strausser, which had its "world premiere" this week-end at the Arts Theatre, time is money. Most of the play takes place in the office of a posh LA therapist who charges $200 per hour. So, having sat through the play, I am wondering why the author spent time writing it, why a production team spent time putting it up and why I and any audience member are asked to spent time (and money) watching it. The play, said to be "a triangle with four corners" (!), brings together a therapist (Tessa Peake-Jones), who is probably not enjoying her job all that much), Lily (Josefina Gabrielle - the eponymous Parc Avenue cat) as well as Philip (Gray O'Brien - aka Tony Gordon in Coronation Street) and Dorian (Daniel Weyman), Lily's lovers. In an interview on the play's dedicated website, Strausser (who was in the audience) explains that he thinks comedy comes out of a

pink sauce | life, with a pink seasoning

As of tonight, my blog Aimless Ramblings of Zefrog , that "place where I can vent my frustration, express ideas and generally open my big gob without bothering too many people" which will be 6 in a couple of months, becomes Pink Sauce . While the URLs zefrog.blogspot.com and www.zefrog.eu are still valid to access this page, the main URL now becomes www.pinksauce.co.uk. There is a vague plan to create a proper website for www.zefrog.eu to which the blog would be linked. Why Pink Sauce , you may ask. It is both simple and complicated. For several years, I have grown out of love for the name of the blog. It felt a bit cumbersome and clumsy. That said, I never really looked into changing it, seriously. Tonight, for dinner, I had pasta with a special pink sauce of my concoction ; single cream and ketchup. I know most people while feel nauseous at the very though of the mixture but trust me, it's gorgeous. Don't knock it till you've tried it. After having had my platte